We all know that states are dealing with huge budget deficits, and that medical costs are skyrocketing. Well, one Utah legislator believes he has come up with a partial solution to the problem: deny epidurals for any pregnant woman on Medicaid.
From the Daily Herald:
Under the theory that perhaps thousands of Utah college students are having babies paid for by Medicaid that they could pay for themselves, one lawmaker has a plan: cut all elective epidurals and elective C-sections.
Sen. Dan Liljenquist, R-Bountiful, has vowed massive Medicaid reform in next year’s legislative session, and first on the list is people who may be freeloading. Medicaid pays for 15,000 births a year in Utah, a third of the total, Liljenquist says.
Appreciate our work?
Rewire is a non-profit independent media publication. Your tax-deductible contribution helps support our research, reporting, and analysis.
“Do we save some kid or make birth easier?” he said, noting that the waiting list for Medicaid in Utah just for the disabled has reached 4,400 people.
Liljenquist says the state could save millions. Epidurals, a shot given in the spine, are a common method of relieving pain during labor. At Utah Valley Regional Medical Center in Provo, 86 to 87 percent of women who deliver babies at the hospital get an epidural; studies show about 65 percent of births nationwide happen with an epidural.
And it’s not just one lawmaker. From the same article:
“These are 90 percent out-of-state students having babies on our dime,” Sen. Howard Stephenson, R-Draper, told Liljenquist, referring to BYU students. Conservative lawmakers have been upset about anecdotal evidence of students with a Lexus and trust fund having a baby under Medicaid. They qualify because there may technically be no income.
During the legislative session earlier this year, Rep. John Dougall, R-Highland, caused a stir for saying the same thing.
So, first you eliminate abortion options so women are forced to give birth should they have a birth control failure, then you tell them it needs to be as painful as possible as well? It’s not surprising that the reaction has been somewhat…passionate.
From Opposing Views:
Denying patients epidural anesthesia is a great way to put misogynistic, classist douchebaggery into action. Rich women will be able to afford paying for pain relief and poor and middle class women will not have access to it. It’s about as thoughtful a move as trying to force more women to breastfeed by making formula available by prescription only.
Sen. Liljenquist claims people are misunderstanding him, according to the Daily Herald in a follow-up. He’s just saying that things that are elective should be treated as such, and not covered. But why doesn’t he just propose eliminating all anesthesia, then, since none of it is “necessary?”
Other legislators and health care policy-makers are quick to point out that Liljenquist is way out of line with his proposal:
Liljenquist has already been the target of radio talk shows and a fellow Republican senator who isn’t impressed with his ideas.
“All I can say is thank God for anesthesia,” said Sen. Peter Knudson, assistant majority whip, who said on KSL Radio that Liljenquist’s pitch is “absolutely not” a good one.
“There are people who have pain thresholds who can tolerate a lot of discomfort, but not everyone,” he said. “I’m all for saving money … but this is not where we should begin.”
Knudson isn’t the only one who isn’t on board with Liljenquist. Lincoln Nehring at the Utah Health Policy Project said the Bountiful Republican is mistaken to think Medicaid is some sort of luxury program.
“Sen. Liljenquist has this belief that it would be better if Medicaid provided subpar care to encourage people to move into the private market,” said Nehring, the project’s Medicaid policy director.
“As a rule, Medicaid doesn’t provide access to optional services,” he said. “Nobody’s getting plastic surgery on the taxpayers’ dime unless it’s really necessary.”
- Denver school clinic offers contraception – Fox 31 KDVR.com
- Abortion is a surprising subtext in a number of key political campaigns in … – FOX CT
- Women delegates call for action again violence, poor maternal health and obesity – Radio New Zealand International
- Florida abortion protestor is target of U.S. Justice Department – Examiner.com
- Merrill Schools Consider Sex Ed Changes – WCCO
- ‘Over 70000 women die in India every year during childbirth’ – Times of India
- After ACLU complaint about Catholic workers refusing to perform abortions … – Catholic News Agency
- Opinion: Costly cuts for family planning services – NorthJersey.com
- Merrill sex ed debate grows – Wausau Daily Herald
- Women serve women at Doula Foundation – News-Leader.com
- Utah lawmaker’s Medicaid proposal draws ire – Daily Herald
- School is Denver’s first to offer contraceptives in fight against teen births – Denver Post
- Louisville lawyer faces 6 months in jail for refusing to reveal client’s name – Louisville Courier-Journal
- Primary election features three ballot choices for some voters – Fairbanks Daily News-Miner
- UNC insurance plan under fire over abortion – News & Observer
- New Mo. abortion law counters some philosophy, theology – St. Louis Post-Dispatch
- 31 already committed to oppose treaty giving world body oversight of parents – WND.com
- Officials sued for stopping prenatal care – Columbus Telegram
- US sues West Palm abortion protester – Palm Beach Post
- Education key to stemming baby dumping – Malaysia Star
- US Catholic bishops press for defunding abortions nationwide – Spero News
- Prenatal pesticide exposure linked to high ADHD risk – Food Consumer
- 2012 Watch: Santorum in New Hampshire following Iowa visit – CNN Political Ticker (blog)
- Complaint filed over proposed sex ed program – KULR-TV
- Birth control pill apparently equally productive for women irrespective of weight – HealthJockey.com
- Prop 2 too heavy a burden for abused teens – Anchorage Daily News
- Modest measure – Fairbanks Daily News-Miner
- Measure 2 won’t help in homes with abuse – Anchorage Daily News
- Balanced measure: Notification preserves a bit of parental involvement – Fairbanks Daily News-Miner
- Meg Whitman says state should defend Prop. 8 – San Francisco Chronicle
- Duggar Family News: 12 Duggars Kids With Chicken Pox – Spreadit
- India pays cash to reduce maternal mortality rate – Richmond Times Dispatch
- New Breast Cancer Committee To Establish Federal Research Agenda – TTKN News
- Viruses may cause more cancer than previously thought – Tehran Times
- Too little, too late – Straits Times
- Helena woman files suit over sex ed curriculum – KRTV Great Falls News
- Woman’s AIDS message goes viral – Chicago Tribune
- Right To Life Group Protests Telemedical Abortions – KCRG
- Pitt County school board adopts new sex education policy – Greenville Daily Reflector
- Utah: Save Money by Denying Women Epidurals – Opposing Views
- Infant Mortality Rate Hits All-time low – WAAY
- Abortion opponents seek to shut down Planned Parenthood’s telemedicine operation – Radio Iowa
- Listen up and listen close – Straits Times (blog)
- No maternal deaths in Bongo for the past three years – Ghana News Agency
- Worker, pro-choice groups sound warnings on Maes-Williams ticket – The Colorado Independent
- NEW LEGISLATION, NEW PILL, OLD PROBLEM FOR AMERICAN WOMEN – OpEdNews
- Mystery of the”basement babies” – Salon
- Parts of New Louisiana Ultrasound Law Blocked – Ms. Magazine
- Legacy of the ladette: Now alarming rise in teenage promiscuity and abortions … – Daily Mail
- Why Is CO Local TV News Ignoring Buck’s Views on Abortion? – Huffington Post (blog)
- bishops urge passage of permanent ban on federal abortion funding – The Hill (blog)
- Parenting is about more than blood – El Estándar
- Opinion: Discrimination hides within ballot measure 2 – Alaskajournal.com
- Bill would hinder crisis pregnancy centers – BP News
- HIV Transmitted During Sex May Hold Clues to Infection – Voice of America
- Greening your birth control: From vegan condoms to the IUD – Creative Loafing Tampa (blog)
- Sarah Palin Should Be Able to Call Herself a Feminist – Newsweek
- Health services must consider cultural issues – AngolaPress
- The female victims of Pakistan’s flood – Salon
- DiNapoli gets Planned Parenthood endorsement – Politics on the Hudson (blog)
- Choosing a Birth Control Method – New York Times (blog)
- The Right’s Long, Racist History of Calling Moms Criminals – ColorLines magazine
- Birth Control, Rent Delay St. Vincent’s Urgent Care Center – Gothamist
- Birth Control Doesn’t Have to Mean the Pill – New York Times
- St. Vincent’s Urgent Care Facility Delayed By Birth Control Issue – DNAinfo
- More US teens get vaccinated, CDC finds – Reuters
- Why We Shouldn’t Look Away From the Mistreatment of Girls Worldwide – Huffington Post (blog)
- Cervical cancer deaths cut – The Australian
- Government to exempt the poor from baby delivery cost – Jakarta Post
- Women Aspirants To Prioritise Maternal Health – MDGs – P.M. News (blog)
- Health in the future: HIV self-destructs with a ‘mix’ – Independent
- Controversial contraceptives rile conservatives – Milwaukee News Buzz
- The Feminist Left Goes Global on Our Money – Canada Free Press
- Alaska ballot measure could limit teen abortions – MiamiHerald.com
- Gender and HIV and AIDS Adviser – OneWorld.net
- Healthcare Friday – The Hill (blog)
- National Committee on Maternal Death Prevention launched Friday – AngolaPress
- A Lesson in the Heritage of this Nation – Lynchburg News and Advance
- Operation Rescue to fight remote abortions – DesMoinesRegister.com
- Repro health bill – Manila Bulletin
- If Ballot Measure 2 passes, here’s how parental notification would work – Anchorage Daily News
- New urgent care clinic at St. Vincent’s in religious hangup over birth control – New York Daily News
- Measure 2 could limit abortion for teens – Anchorage Daily News
- Maternal health film showcases stories of mothers – IBNLive.com
- ‘Sex education’ at last… in 1Malaysia – Aliran Monthly