Analysis Human Rights

Is ICE Trying to End Public Oversight of Detention Conditions?

Renée Feltz

Stakeholder tours, coupled with visitation programs and calls to the Community Initiatives for Visiting Immigrants in Confinement hotline for detainees, often help volunteers decide which facilities most need independent oversight.

Since Donald Trump took office and began a crackdown on undocumented immigrants, human rights advocates say Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has frequently refused to comply with a little-known policy that allows the public to monitor conditions in detention centers.

“It feels like a pattern,” Christina Fialho, co-executive director of Community Initiatives for Visiting Immigrants in Confinement (CIVIC), told Rewire during a phone interview about how ICE rejected six of the group’s requests for access in the past two months.

Fialho’s organization helps a national network of volunteers follow “stakeholder procedures” established in 2011 to provide independent oversight of a sprawling system of more than 200 private detention centers and county jails, which currently hold a record 41,000 immigrants in what are supposed to be civil and non-punitive conditions.

Separate from ICE’s standards for meetings with lawyers and family members in the visitation area, the agency’s so-called “Access Directive” outlines how individuals or groups can tour the rest of a facility if they send a request at least two weeks in advance to the ICE field officer who oversees it, along with several proposed dates.

Appreciate our work?

Rewire is a non-profit independent media publication. Your tax-deductible contribution helps support our research, reporting, and analysis.

DONATE NOW

“You can see the medical unit, the kitchen, and dorms,” Fialho explained. “ICE is also required to post sign-up sheets for visits that allow us to visit with people in detention who we don’t have to pre-identify.”

But last month, the D.C. Detention Visitation Network received an unexpected rejection when it asked to tour and visit the Farmville Detention Center in Virginia, run by Immigration Centers of America.

“Farmville holds the largest number of immigrants in detention within hours of D.C.,” Erin Hustings, coordinator of the DC Detention Visitation Network, told Rewire. “We’ve always had it in mind as a place to reach out to.”

The group’s ultimate goal, Hustings explained, was to set up a visitation program similar to those it has run for several years at two jails in Maryland. Despite their established track record, ICE had other plans.

“With the issuance of the recent executive orders, ICE is undergoing significant operational changes and is in the process of reviewing all ongoing programs,” read an email response to their request from Assistant ICE Field Office Director Matthew Munroe. He explained the agency is “not initiating new programs such as the one you are proposing at this time.”

“It was unusual,” said Hustings. “But I guess not surprising given the moment we’re in,” she added, referring to an executive order Trump signed days after his inauguration. The measure orders ICE to “take all appropriate actions to ensure the detention of aliens apprehended for violations of immigration law pending the outcome of their removal proceedings or their removal from the country to the extent permitted by law.”

Farmville and five other rejections since January 20 are detailed in a complaint CIVIC filed this month with the Department of Homeland Security’s Office of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties (CRCL). A spokesperson confirmed to Rewire that the office “has received the complaint and it is currently being processed.”

The group showed Rewire a response from ICE’s Acting Director, Thomas Homan, that said the agency “appreciates the work of CIVIC and other community-based visitation programs” and has a “strong desire” to continue to facilitate their access to immigration detention facilities.

ICE’s acting press secretary, Jennifer D. Elzea, declined further comment to Rewire because of the pending CRCL complaint.

Responding to the recent spate of denials, Human Rights Watch and the American Civil Liberties Union joined CIVIC and more than 400 other groups and individuals in writing a letter to ICE this month urging it to ensure public access and oversight of immigrant detention.

Among the signatories were many Unitarian Universalist churches who started detention visitation programs around the country after congregants voted to focus on “Immigration as a Moral Issue” from 2010-2014.

“We learned a lot and then we wanted to take action,” said Jan Meslin, a Unitarian who helped found Friends of Orange County Detainees in 2012, and has since advised others on how to set-up similar programs. “Some of our members are hesitant because they have not been to a jail or a detention center before, but when we go in as a group it’s not so scary.”

She said she has been on five tours of ICE facilities, which “make it more meaningful when I come back as a visitor because I understand where they are living.”

Stakeholder tours, coupled with visitation programs and calls to CIVIC’s hotline for detainees—which have doubled to 14,000 per month since January, Fialho said—often help volunteers decide which facilities most need independent oversight.

This is what happened at the Theo Lacy Facility in Orange, California, a maximum-security jail outside of Los Angeles holding about 500 immigrants, including many who were arrested by ICE in recent raids. After callers complained of spoiled food and other abusive treatment, CIVIC helped document multiple incidents of physical assault by guards, denied medical care, and excessive use of solitary confinement.

“It was a terrible place,” a former detainee at Theo Lacy, whom Meslin used to visit, told Rewire. He asked to remain anonymous in order to avoid jeopardizing his supervised release while his asylum claim is pending. “You’re locked up in a cell 23 hours a day with no access to the phones except for 5-6 am in the morning, and who can you call then?”

CIVIC alerted the Homeland Security’s Office of Inspector General (OIG), prompting officials to conduct an unannounced inspection last November. The findings are the basis of a damning OIG report issued this month. Still, ICE says its Los Angeles Field Office hasn’t reset a date for a new stakeholder tour and visit after the Orange County Sheriff’s Department denied the last request.

In December, ICE’s Phoenix Field Office announced it would allow just one tour a month at each of its four facilities in Arizona, which have a combined capacity of more than 6,000. All but one are run by the private prison corporation CoreCivic, formerly known as Corrections Corporation of America. Fifteen people have died at the company’s Eloy Detention Center since 2003.

This comes as Trump’s Attorney General Jeff Sessions instructed the Federal Bureau of Prisons in February to once again contract with private prison corporations that contributed large sums to Trump’s 2016 campaign and inauguration, despite the DOJ’s findings that they had failed to maintain adequate levels of safety and security for detainees.

Trump’s immigration policy experts estimate increased immigration enforcement could rapidly double the number of people in detention to 80,000 people per day. Another private prison corporation, GEO Group, plans to open a new 780-bed facility in Georgia, and ICE recently signed a contract with CoreCivic to use as a detention center a former New Mexico prison that lost its federal contract after The Nation exposed how inmates there suffered from severe medical neglect.

In light of this rapid expansion amid repeated efforts to scale back independent oversight of detention operators with poor track records, CIVIC issued a letter this month calling on ICE to honor nine upcoming tours scheduled at the agency’s facilities. Included among them is Prairieland Detention Center near Dallas, Texas, run by Emerald Correctional Management. It has a new unit set aside for transgender immigrants that was established after volunteer visitors helped document problems faced by LGBTQ detainees in the center’s general population, including sexual assault, degrading strip-searches, and long-term solitary confinement.

“I am grateful that over the past several years ICE has seen wisdom in working collaboratively with outside organizations to … show it has nothing to hide,” Hustings told Rewire. “I hope the people there now will recognize the heightened importance of continuing to do so.”

Load More

Reproductive rights are a public health issue. That's a fact.

Thank you for reading Rewire!