Roundup: “Is It Anti-Woman Day in the Missouri House?”

Robin Marty

It was anti-woman day in the Missouri House, as pharmacists earned the right to refuse birth control and more "informed" consent rules pass.

“Is it anti-woman day in the Missouri House? Not sure if it’s all that different from the other days, though.”

It was a sad tweet from Planned Parenthood Missouri, sad but seemingly true, as yesterday one small victory was overshadowed by a variety of bills meant to stifle women’s bodily autonomy.

The good news was that Personhood Missouri failed to gather enough signatures to get a “fertilized egg is a person” amendment onto the ballot for 2010.  The not so good news is that Missouri Legislature took up the anti-choice banner on their own, working two new bills to restrict reproductive health access for women.

First, a House committee passed an expanded “informed consent” bill.  The information is already provided to a woman in advance of the procedure, but this new requirement would make women receive the information in person rather than on the phone, adding an additional visit to the process and causing more issues with delay and access.

Appreciate our work?

Rewire is a non-profit independent media publication. Your tax-deductible contribution helps support our research, reporting, and analysis.


Missouri law already requires that a woman be provided information about her physical and psychological risks at least 24 hours before having an abortion.

The legislation would require that the consultation occur in person instead of over the phone and that women be given details about fetal development. Abortion providers also would have to give women a chance to see an ultrasound and listen to a heartbeat.

A Planned Parenthood spokesperson notes that the information provided to the women is more propaganda than simple fetal development notes.

Planned Parenthood, a pro-choice group, says the rules would be too stringent.

“These new burdensome requirements are unnecessary because women who seek abortions now go through an exhaustive informed consent process,” Planned Parenthood of Missouri chief executive officer Paula Gianino said in a telephone interview.

Furthermore, Planned Parenthood says the written information that would be given out is pure right wing rhetoric.

“For instance, that the abortion ‘is killing the life of a separate unique living human being.’ These are just attempts by anti-abortion and anti-choice groups to try and shame women and make this process all the more difficult for women,” said Gianino.

“These are difficult decisions and women don’t make them lightly, and women know that this is a decision that becomes part of their lives forever,” said Gianino.

But limiting access to abortion isn’t enough.  Anti-choice legislators feel the need to reduce access to emergency contraception, too.

The Missouri House has voted to let pharmacies decide whether to stock the “morning-after” emergency contraceptive pill.

The provision was added by a 109-42 vote Tuesday to a broader bill on state licensing. The bill now goes back to the Senate.

The measure would bar legal action against pharmacies that refuse to provide the abortion drug known as RU-486 or the emergency “morning-after” contraception sold as Plan B. Pharmacies would not be obligated to advise people how to get the drugs.

Missouri licensing officials say there are currently no state pharmacy regulations on contraceptives.

Supporters say the measure would give pharmacies the freedom to choose what they sell. Critics say it could result in more woman having abortions.

It should come as little surprise that the sponsor of the bill not only seems unclear what the various drugs he’s exempting pharmacists from having to dispense do, but may have allowed them to not provide most forms of contraceptives all together.

The amendment, sponsored by Rep. Ed Emery, R-Lamar, states that a pharmacist isn’t required to carry or dispense any medication that is used to induce an abortion. It also says a pharmacy can not be sued for refusing to dispense the drugs, or any other drug categorized as an abortifacient.

Emery said the amendment gives pharmacists protection from frivolous lawsuits and protects their profession. But it’s a move that some Democrats say could stop pharmacists from being required to dispense any type of birth control.

“This would have the impact of allowing pharmacists to refuse to fill prescriptions for birth control pills,” said Rep. Beth Low, D-Kansas City. “This is basic state interference with one of the most important and sacred personal relationships — the relationship between doctor and patient.”‘

Rep. Jeanette Mott-Oxford, D-St. Louis, said the bill is “medically and scientifically inaccurate,” as it makes comparisons between RU 486 and emergency contraception, the two drugs specifically mentioned in the amendment.

Yes, it seems it really was anti-woman day in the Missouri House.

Mini-Roundup: Only could turn this into this.

May 4, 2010

Okla. agrees not to enforce restrictive abortion law pending legal challenge – USA Today

Abortion rights groups warned of backlash –

Abortion law suspended – Tulsa World

Anti-Hyde Pushback Sparked by Health Care Battle – WomensRadio

Why parental consent laws are necessary – Chicago Tribune

Chipping Away at Abortion Rights – CounterPunch

Liberals hope to profit from Tory profanity on abortion – Globe and Mail

Most Women Pay For Abortions Out Of Pocket; Okla. And Fla. Abortion … – Kaiser Health News

Sen. Mike Bennett Caught Looking at Porn During Abortion Debate – Miami New Times

G8 abortion debate: Should it be on the agenda? –

Christie, Shunning Precedent, Drops Justice From Court – New York Times

Anti-‘personhood’ coalition regroups, begins campaign – The Colorado Independent

‘No change’ on abortion policy: CIDA –

Abortion Rates Rising Among the Poor – BusinessWeek

Abortion clinic will move; foes will, too – Minneapolis Star Tribune

Senate Committee to Vote on Pro-Abortion Obama Judicial Pick Goodwin Liu –

Foster mother: DHS pressured teen into an abortion – World Magazine

Anti-abortion endorsement puts Crist in corner –

Fla. Senator Peeks at Porn During Abortion Debate – NBC Miami

Ruth’s abortion comment ‘intimidation’: MPs –

Kansas House Votes to Override Abortion Bill Veto – Ms. Magazine

Abortion concentrated among poor women – Los Angeles Times

Oklahoma Passes Controversial Abortion Laws – GlobalShift

Fifty Years Later, 86% of Americans Believe Having “the Pill” Available Is … – NewsBlaze

Where women still don’t own their bodies – Sydney Morning Herald

US Teen Births Still Highest Among Industrialized Nations – Medical News Today

Pill might wreak havoc in bedroom – TheMedGuru

Happy 50th, Birth Control Pill! – Village Voice

It’s official: birth control does lower sex drive – True/Slant

72% of Filipinos say condom use beneficial for HIV-AIDS prevention – Business Mirror

Los Angeles Times Examines STI, Unintended Pregnancy Rates Among Young Adults – Medical News Today

Romania denies over 1000 HIV sufferers access to vital healthcare – The Diplomat

Men With HPV at Higher Risk for HIV, Study Finds – MSN Health & Fitness

50th Anniversary of The Pill: Triumph and Controversy – Center for Media and Democracy

Anti-Hyde Pushback Sparked by Health Care Battle – WomensRadio

Most Women Pay for Their Own Abortions – Wall Street Journal

Study Shows Half of Women Getting Second Abortion, Don’t Use Private Insurance –

Study shows vitamin A doesn’t cut maternal deaths – Reuters

Midwives’ leader warns against ‘baby factories’ – The Guardian

Do ‘family values’ weaken families? – Brisbane Times

Maternal health: Should you speak up or stay quiet? – Globe and Mail

Under bill approved by Missouri House, pharmacists could refuse to dispense … – Kansas City Star

Abortion debate over 24-hour wait begins – The State

Missouri Personhood Amendment on Abortion Fails to Qualify for November Ballot –

Obama interviews Diane Wood for Supreme Court – The Associated Press

Abortion bill deserves a veto –

Legislators propose stricter rules for abortion seekers in MO – KY3

Missouri House committee advances bill to expand informed consent on abortions – Kansas City Star

Missouri House okays amendment that could reduce access to morning-after pill – St. Louis Post-Dispatch

Abortion battle rages in Topeka – KSN-TV

Taxpayers To Foot The Bill For Oklahoma Abortion Lawsuit – News On 6

Funding Cut to Women’s Groups by Conservative Government –

50 years on, the pill still changes lives – Laredo Sun

May 5, 2010

Abortion bill allows choice – Tampa Tribune

Stifles abortion debate – Ottawa Citizen

Abortion wait period faces delay – Greenville News

Women Living in Poverty Make Up Increasing Share of Patients Seeking Abortion Care – AlterNet

Nancy Ruth is right that it’s not just abortion – Globe and Mail

Judicial bypass works – Philadelphia Daily News

Anti-abortion group sues for club funding – Vancouver Sun

Dr Ruth hails the pill that revolutionized women’s lives – AFP


‘The Pill’ Changed The Sexual Landscape – Hartford Courant

Ending HIV/AIDS Pandemic Still the Goal, Fauci Says – Medscape

Topics and Tags:

Missouri, Planned Parenthood

Load More

We report on health, rights, and justice. Now, more than ever, we need your support to fight for our independent reporting.

Thank you for reading Rewire!