Science Based Approach to HIV/AIDS Returns to South Africa
South Africa’s new Health Minister, Barbara Hogan, said on Monday at the International AIDS Vaccine Conference 2008 in Cape Town that Thabo Mbeki’s
government wasted time in fighting HIV/AIDS and vowed to step up
efforts after years of controversy when her predecessor advocated
beetroot and garlic as treatment. South Africa, which has one of the world’s heaviest HIV caseloads,
has been accused by activists of dragging its feet in dealing with the
disease which kills an estimated 1,000 people every day. No longer:
At the opening of the International AIDS Vaccine Conference 2008 in
Cape Town the new Minister of Health, Barbara Hogan, repeatedly
stressed the importance of scientific, "evidence-based responses" to
Appreciate our work?
Rewire is a non-profit independent media publication. Your tax-deductible contribution helps support our research, reporting, and analysis.
Hogan said to the South African government and people about the
vaccine conference: "There can’t be any other more important meeting at
Vice-Chancellor of the University of KwaZulu-Natal,
Professor Malegapuru Makgoba, won applause from the delegates when he
welcomed the new attitude to HIV science by the ministers.
"We (can say) confidently that HIV causes Aids without threats. It is liberating."
In striking contrast to the previous health minister,
Hogan acknowledged that South Africa had "lost ground" to the epidemic
and that Aids was killing young South Africans.
She said the government was committed "to scale-up
mother-to-child prevention programmes" and stated that HIV and TB were
the primary health challenges in South Africa.
"We know that HIV causes AIDS," said Hogan, a point that former president Thabo Mbeki publicly contested.
"… It was imperative to get ahead of the curve of this epidemic
ten years ago. We all, for various reasons, have lost ground. We also wasted time despite having one of the best plans to cope
with the epidemic," Hogan said, adding South Africa must now show more
urgency in implementing a national program launched last year to
Mbeki drew sharp criticism shortly after coming to power in 1999
when he questioned accepted AIDS science and failed to make
life-prolonging anti-retroviral drugs (ARVs) widely available.
Tshabalala-Msimang has been lampooned by leading scientists and
activists for recommending garlic and beetroot as treatments.
Famous Indian Authors Tell Real Stories of HIV and Sex Worker Suffering
Time Magazine today reviewed a new book, AIDS Sutra: Untold Stories From India, in which acclaimed Indian authors, like Salman Rushdie, Siddhartha Deb and William Dalrymple, travel around the country and memorialize the accounts of those who suffer most from the HIV pandemic:
With its diversity of perspectives and voices, this collection provides
a uniquely intimate glimpse into a disease that is either sterilized by
statistics or ignored altogether. Each story reveals a government and
culture that, like so many other nations, still denies the HIV’s
impact. Yet even with its pages filled with so much injustice and pain,
the book also contains its fair share of triumphant moments. An
HIV-positive doctor who fought for his constitutional right to marry a
"negative" woman — and won; a group of HIV-positive children who found
a home when no one else would take them, a sex worker who braves police
corruption and abuse to spread condoms to her colleagues. As one women
explained: "I know I am HIV positive, but it is only a condition, not a
curse. I have the right to live a normal life."
Researchers Work on Cream that Can Stop HIV Transmission
Despite the long road microbicide research has traveled with little success hope remains that this method of defense against the spread of HIV will eventually arrive at success. Dr. James Hildreth and his team at the Center for AIDS Health Disparities Research at Meharry Medical College are developing a cream that could potentially block the transmission of HIV during sex. The cream is designed with women in mind, especially women in Africa who "have no way of protecting themselves from HIV transmission, as well as
black women in the United States who are disproportionately affected by
The vaginal cream, described as a "chemical condom," relies on a
sugar found in toothpaste and mouthwash to remove cholesterol the HIV
virus needs to spread. The cream is odorless and is designed to be
undetectable to a woman’s sexual partner.
"In many parts of the
world, women are not in the position to negotiate how sex is
practiced," including the use of condoms, Hildreth said. "We have been
trying to formulate something transparent to the act of having sex.
Women might be able to use it without getting permission or even
letting the men know they are using it."
Earlier this summer,
Hildreth traveled to Lusaka, Zambia, to see how women and men reacted
to the feel and the smell of the cream. About 1.1 million Zambians, 17
percent of the adult population, were living with HIV in 2005,
according to the United Nations.
Researchers expected men to reject the cream, but most accepted it.
Catholic University Forces NPR Station to Refuse Funding From Planned Parenthood
(Via Feministe) Former Catholic Duquense University student Michelle Pilicki writes at HuffingtonPost.com that her alma mater asked its NPR affiliate station WDUQ to "refuse underwriting from Planned Parenthood." Planned Parenthood was running the following underwriter statements on the air at WDUQ:
Support for DUQ comes from Planned Parenthood, offering healthcare
services to men, including screenings for cancer and STDs. Planned
Parenthood: Their mission is prevention.
Support for DUQ comes from Planned Parenthood, providing comprehensive
sexuality education, including lessons on abstinence. Planned
Parenthood: Their mission is prevention.
Support for DUQ comes from Planned Parenthood, whose community
educators empower teens to make good choices by teaching self-esteem.
Planned Parenthood: Their mission is prevention.
Support for DUQ comes from Planned Parenthood, offering cancer
screenings for women and men. Planned Parenthood: Their mission is
Of course, Planned Parenthood’s main business is education, screening for potential disease and dispensing subsidized birth control. Despite the fact that all of the underwriter statements were focused only on these generally accepted and certainly much needed social services the university asked the NPR affiliate to refuse money from the organization.
Pilecki goes on to argue for the evidence-based middle ground where more and more common-sense people are meeting on this issue:
Even more to the point, undercutting the efforts of Planned Parenthood is more likely to increase, not decrease the demand for abortion. Serendipitously, today’s New York Times reported
on a worldwide study of abortion rates, quoting Dr. Paul Van Look,
director of the World Health Organization’s department of reproductive
health and research:
We now have a global picture of induced abortion in the
world, covering both countries where it is legal and countries where
laws are very restrictive. What we see is that the law does not
influence a woman’s decision to have an abortion. If there’s an
unplanned pregnancy, it does not matter if the law is restrictive or
The study, published in Lancet (you can read the 13-page pdf here),
says the data also suggest that the best way to reduce abortion rates
was not to make abortion illegal but to make contraception more widely
available. The highest rates of abortion are in countries that outlaw
abortion; not surprisingly, these are also the places with the highest
rates of maternal death from abortion complications. The lowest
abortion rates? In Western Europe, where abortion is not only legal,
but contraception is also available as part of citizens’ universal
A Mother’s Final Look at Life
In case you missed it, a special report in the Washington Post this past Sunday told the story of Fatmata Jollah who died at 18 while giving birth in Sierra Leone, which has the highest rate of maternal mortality in the world. Fatmata’s story provides a human face to the startling numbers of maternal deaths:
More than 500,000 women a year — about one every minute — die in
childbirth across the globe, almost exclusively in the developing
world, and almost always from causes preventable with basic medical
care. The planet’s worst rates are in this startlingly poor nation on
West Africa’s Atlantic coast, where a decade of civil war that ended in
2002 deepened chronic deprivation.
According to the United Nations,
a woman’s chance of dying in childbirth in the United States is 1 in
4,800. In Ireland, which has the best rate in the world, it is 1 in
48,000. In Sierra Leone, it is 1 in 8.
Maternal mortality rarely gets attention from international donors,
who are far more focused on global health threats such as malaria,
tuberculosis and HIV-AIDS. "Maternal death is an almost invisible
death," said Thoraya A. Obaid, executive director of the U.N.
Amie recently wrote a great post taking a close look at the maternal health crisis our world faces that includes some scientifically accepted ways to start to reduce that number and achieve the fifth Millennium Development Goal, to reduce maternal deaths, including improved access to family planning services, prenatal care and maternal education.