Who Delivers the News Matters

Lisa Witter notices that only one of eight anchors during CNN's Super Tuesday coverage was a woman.

This post was part of our live-blogging of Super Tuesday.

I’m blogging from 35,000 feet while watching DirectTV on Jet Blue. When choosing my return trip from San Francisco to New York City tonight I knew I had to pick one of the only airlines that would allow me to watch the results live while zipping through the air.

The “Best Political Team in News,” as CNN describes itself, has minute-to-minute coverage of, unarguably, the most exciting election of my life. I turn to CNN whenever there is breaking-news as my “trusted source” on cable. But watching tonight, I can’t help but be distracted by who’s delivering the results.

In the main political segment there are two rows of desks with four analysts at each. Out of the eight commentators only one of them is a woman. I find this ironic considering that a significant part of the analysis is the role of women voters and the fairing of the first ever woman presidential candidate.* You can bet that the gender imbalance on the tube isn’t because anyone over at CNN is overtly sexist or that they don’t value women’s opinions. I know they do. In fact, they are committed to working with more women. It could be that they couldn’t find enough women commentators to go on or it was an innocent oversight. But by just adding one more woman to their panel they would have doubled female representation.

I’m not saying that every news panel should be perfect mirror of the demographic percentages of the country. But, it does seem like smart television to get a little closer on representing 50% of the population on this pivotal night. Imagine if men tuned into the results and 7 out of 8 commentators where women. They’d be a bit surprised too. Or, they’d think it was a show for women only – better yet, The View. This is one of the reasons it’s so hard for women in politics and leadership. Women and girls don’t see themselves as experts and men often don’t see them as such either. It becomes a self- fulfilling prophecy. A cycle that is hard to break. There is no doubt that elections are primarily about who the next President may be. But they are also a time for us to pay attention to who’s delivering the news, how it’s being filtered and what the effects are.

Just as change seems to be a winning slogan in this election it would be good for all of us if the news changed to be more representative.
For more on closing the gender gap in the media, check out www.shesource.org.

*Later in the evening they did add another female commentator.